Reviews of Search Results: Do It Yourself vs. Chat GPT

10/17/2023

When trying to incorporate a graphic novel into an art class, choosing which book to choose is not an easy task.

First of all, if you don't have time to read all the huge amount of graphic novels or don't know which book to read first, you may be in trouble. In this case, first asking ChatGPT for recommended books will help save time and reduce trial and error.

Reviews of Search Results: Do It Yourself vs. Chat GPT

First, below is a case where a graphic novel to be applied to an art class was recommended using ChatGPT.

ChatGPT provided the answer very clearly and quickly.

Certainly, there are many graphic novels that can be used in art classes to explore various artistic styles, techniques, and storytelling methods. Here are some graphic novels that are not only artistically rich but can also be used to teach different aspects of visual storytelling and illustration:

"Maus" by Art Spiegelman: This Pulitzer Prize-winning graphic novel explores the Holocaust using anthropomorphic animals. It's a powerful example of how visual elements can convey complex and emotionally charged narratives.
"Blankets" by Craig Thompson: This coming-of-age graphic novel showcases Thompson's intricate, detailed artwork and is a great choice for studying composition and panel layout.
"Understanding Comics" by Scott McCloud: While not a traditional graphic novel, this book is a comic about comics. It delves into the theory and art of comics, making it a valuable resource for understanding the medium itself.
"Asterios Polyp" by David Mazzucchelli: This graphic novel is known for its innovative design, which plays with different art styles and layouts to represent the emotional states of the characters.
"The Arrival" by Shaun Tan: This wordless graphic novel is a great example of visual storytelling and can be used to explore how an artist conveys a narrative without relying on text.
"Building Stories" by Chris Ware: A unique work that consists of multiple, interconnected comics, pamphlets, and other printed materials, "Building Stories" challenges the conventions of storytelling and offers a creative look at narrative structure and design.
"The Sculptor" by Scott McCloud: This graphic novel explores the life of a struggling artist who makes a deal with death in exchange for extraordinary sculpting abilities. It provides opportunities for discussions on art, creativity, and mortality.
"Akira" by Katsuhiro Otomo: A classic in the world of manga, "Akira" is known for its highly detailed artwork and intricate cityscapes, making it a great choice for studying architecture and background design.
"Bacchus" by Eddie Campbell: This graphic novel series blends mythology, history, and everyday life with a unique art style, offering a different approach to storytelling and illustration.
"The Arrival" by Shaun Tan: This wordless graphic novel is a beautiful exploration of immigration, displacement, and adapting to a new world, using intricate and imaginative visuals.

Below are 10 graphic novels suggested by a blogger.

As you can see, there are books that overlap with the books selected by AI. In my case, the content presented by the blogger was more impressive. Because it was presented graphically, it was easy to understand, and because it presented personal experiences, it was fun and empathetic while reading. Additionally, some bloggers even present their own trial and error process, which helps reduce mistakes.

https://theartofeducation.edu/2015/10/the-top-10-graphic-novels-to-use-in-your-secondary-art-room/

In my case, I can't forget my experience when I first used ChatGPT. Along with the fear that the world will soon change into a world dominated by artificial intelligence, I also worry that it will be difficult for people like me who have worked with handmade items to make a living.

However, as I get used to artificial intelligence, I also fall into a kind of boredom and slump. In other words, we know that artificial intelligence is still insufficient in many ways to replace humans. When it comes to searches, I find human-generated results fresher, interactive and more informative. This is because it comes from experience, so it is much more empathetic and easy to follow from the perspective of a human who will have the same experience. In the case of artificial intelligence, although it always provides exemplary as if they were an upright person and perfect answers, it often ends with "Wow! That's amazing." In other words, there is no feeling of empathy or communication. So, my usage of artificial intelligence is gradually decreasing. It is often used when I want to use a different expression while writing, or when it is difficult to search because the data is too updated and has rarely been exposed on the Internet.

However, in this case, when I asked about the advantages of graphic novels or wanted to quickly find an accurate answer to an unknown area, artificial intelligence always gave me good results.

I asked the artificial intelligence the following question.

As an artist, you might be particularly interested in graphic novels that showcase unique and visually striking artwork, explore the creative process, or delve into the world of art and artists. Here are some graphic novels that artists may find inspiring and insightful:

"The Arrival" by Shaun Tan: This wordless graphic novel features highly detailed and imaginative artwork, making it a great source of inspiration for artists. It tells a story of immigration and adaptation through its captivating visuals.
"Pablo" by Julie Birmant and Clément Oubrerie: This graphic novel explores the life and art of the famous artist Pablo Picasso. It offers a visual journey through Picasso's creative evolution and the art world of his time.
"Vincent" by Barbara Stok: "Vincent" is a graphic biography of Vincent van Gogh. It provides a unique visual representation of the artist's life, his struggles, and his iconic works.
"The Art of Charlie Chan Hock Chye" by Sonny Liew: This graphic novel combines a fictional biography of a Singaporean comic artist with a commentary on the history of comics in Singapore. It's a thought-provoking work for those interested in the artistic and cultural aspects of comics.
"How to Be an Artist" by Jerry Saltz: While not a traditional graphic novel, this book uses comic-style illustrations to provide insightful advice and guidance for aspiring artists. It's a humorous and educational resource for artists.
"My Favorite Thing Is Monsters" by Emil Ferris: This graphic novel is presented in the form of a young girl's notebook, filled with intricate drawings and illustrations. It's a compelling work of art that tells a coming-of-age story with a unique artistic style.
"The Wall: Growing Up Behind the Iron Curtain" by Peter Sís: This autobiographical graphic novel uses stunning, evocative illustrations to recount the author's experiences growing up in Czechoslovakia during the Cold War.
"Brush with Passion: The Art and Life of Dave Stevens" by Dave Stevens and Mark Schultz: This graphic novel celebrates the life and artwork of the late artist Dave Stevens, known for creating "The Rocketeer." It's a testament to the power of artistic passion and dedication.
"Pollock Confidential" by Onofrio Catacchio: This graphic novel offers a fictionalized take on the life of abstract expressionist painter Jackson Pollock, featuring engaging artwork and a glimpse into the world of the art scene in the mid-20th century.
"Blankets" by Craig Thompson: Known for its beautiful and detailed artwork, "Blankets" is a coming-of-age graphic novel that explores personal experiences, family, and faith through captivating visuals.

These graphic novels vary in style and content, but each offers something valuable to artists, whether it's artistic inspiration, a glimpse into the lives of famous artists, or insights into the creative process.

The answers provided by artificial intelligence are graphic novels that provide valid reasons and evidence that an artist would have chosen.

So what about graphic novels selected by humans and artists rather than artificial intelligence? Below is a story about a book recommended by an artist blogger from an artistic perspective.

This is because reading is an act of reading, empathizing, and communicating with the author's subjective experience, indirect/direct experience. Therefore, sharing these experiences can be more helpful in selecting books that students can relate to in actual art classes.

Art classes and graphic novels are interconnected in several ways, as both involve elements of visual storytelling and creativity.

The skills and concepts learned in art classes can be directly applied to the creation of graphic novels, making these two forms of artistic expression closely related. In the future, we will often see cases like this where graphic novels are used in actual classroom settings, the popularity of novels with beautiful graphics, and cases where graphic novels themselves become art.

Especially, graphic novels are poised to play a more prominent role in education, literature, and the art world in the future. Their appeal lies in their unique combination of visual and narrative storytelling, and as the medium continues to evolve, it will open up exciting possibilities for creators and readers alike.

Considering this importance, art teachers may need to focus on more subjective experiences. However, personally, I think it would be better to use artificial intelligence search for reasons such as whether it violates the law, is not overly sensational or violent, or requires a more in-depth approach within the bounds of subjective experience.

And from the perspective of an artist, when I tried to classify graphic novels to apply them to art classes, I found that I, too, thought that visual and artistic impact was more important when searching. So, I discovered the vision that when graphic novels faithfully fulfill their role as visual storytellers, this genre can play an active and important role not only in art classes but also in other areas.

0 Comments

Blog for visual thinkers and artists ...